Coats Moon vs Gütermann Sew-All: Which Polyester Sewing Thread Should You Choose?

If you're looking for a reliable general-purpose polyester sewing thread, two names you'll often come across are Coats Moon and Gütermann Sew-All.

Both are established sewing thread ranges designed for everyday sewing, dressmaking, repairs and alterations. So if you're trying to decide between them, which should you choose?

Is Gutermann Sew-All better than Coats Moon? Is Coats Moon a good alternative? And does it actually matter which brand you use?

The short answer is that both are excellent choices for general-purpose sewing, and in many projects the most important factors are the thread type, colour, fabric and your sewing machine settings rather than the brand alone.

Let's compare them. For a broader overview of the Gutermann thread range, including Natural Cotton and Maraflex, see our Gütermann Sewing Thread Guide.

Coats Moon vs Gütermann Sew-All at a Glance

The most important thing to understand is that Coats Moon and Gütermann Sew-All are both general-purpose polyester threads.

This makes them much more directly comparable than, for example, Gutermann Sew-All and Gutermann Maraflex, which has been specifically designed for flexible seams. See our Gütermann Maraflex vs Sew-All guide for more on that.

What Is Coats Moon?

Coats Moon is a general-purpose polyester sewing thread designed for everyday sewing applications.

It's commonly used for clothing, repairs, alterations and a wide range of household sewing and craft projects.

Because it is a general-purpose thread, it's a useful option to keep in your sewing box when you need a thread that can work across a variety of projects.

Coats Moon is suitable for:

• General sewing

• Dressmaking

• Clothing

• Repairs

• Alterations

• Sewing machine projects

• Hand sewing

• Cotton fabrics

• Polyester fabrics

• Craft projects

• Everyday sewing

If you're looking for a practical polyester sewing thread for everyday jobs, Coats Moon is a popular option.

What Is Gütermann Sew-All?

Gütermann Sew-All is a general-purpose polyester sewing thread designed for a wide range of sewing applications.

It's suitable for household sewing machines and hand sewing and is widely used for dressmaking, repairs, alterations and everyday sewing.

The “Sew-All” name reflects its intended versatility: it's designed to be a useful general-purpose thread rather than a specialist thread for one particular application.

Gutermann Sew-All is suitable for:

• General sewing

• Dressmaking

• Clothing

• Repairs

• Alterations

• Sewing machine projects

• Hand sewing

• Cotton fabrics

• Polyester fabrics

• Lightweight fabrics

• Medium-weight fabrics

• Craft projects

Shop Gütermann Sew-All Polyester Thread

Are Coats Moon and Gütermann Sew-All the Same?

Not exactly, but they're very similar in terms of their intended use.

Both are polyester general-purpose sewing threads.

That means you can use either for many of the same types of projects.

The differences are more likely to come down to the individual product specifications, thread construction, colour range, spool size, price and your own preferences.

So if you're standing in a sewing shop trying to decide between a spool of Coats Moon and Gütermann Sew-All, you don't necessarily need to worry that choosing one will make your project impossible.

Both are designed for everyday sewing.

Which Is Better for Dressmaking?

For general dressmaking, both Coats Moon and Gütermann Sew-All can be good choices.

If you're making a woven garment such as:

• A blouse

• A shirt

• A skirt

• Trousers

• A dress

• A jacket

• Children's clothing

a general-purpose polyester sewing thread is often appropriate.

The most important consideration is to make sure your thread is suitable for the fabric and construction method you're using.

Gütermann Sew-All

A good choice if you want a versatile polyester thread and already use other Gütermann products.

Coats Moon

A good choice if you're familiar with Moon and want a dependable everyday polyester thread.

In many dressmaking projects, colour matching will be more important than whether you choose Moon or Sew-All.

Which Is Better for Sewing Cotton Fabric?

Interestingly, you don't have to use cotton thread just because you're sewing cotton fabric.

Both Coats Moon and Gütermann Sew-All are polyester threads and can be used for many cotton-fabric projects.

Your choice may depend on the purpose of the project.

If you're making a cotton dress, shirt or bag, a general-purpose polyester thread may be perfectly appropriate.

If you're quilting or patchworking and specifically want a 100% cotton thread, that's where Gütermann Natural Cotton becomes a useful alternative. See our Gütermann Sew-All vs Natural Cotton guide for more detail.

Shop Gütermann Natural Cotton

Which Is Better for Repairs and Alterations?

Both are suitable for many everyday repairs and alterations.

If you're repairing:

• Trousers

• Shirts

• Dresses

• Skirts

• Jackets

• Children's clothes

• Household textiles

the key things to consider are the fabric, the existing stitching and the colour you need.

For a repair that needs to be as unobtrusive as possible, finding a close colour match is often more important than choosing between Moon and Sew-All.

Which Is Better for a Sewing Machine?

Both are suitable for household sewing machines.

However, remember that thread is only one part of getting a good stitch.

Your machine settings, needle, fabric and thread all work together.

If you're experiencing problems such as:

• Thread breaking

• Uneven stitches

• Loops on the underside

• Skipped stitches

• Poor tension

don't automatically assume the thread is the problem.

Check your:

1. Needle type

2. Needle size

3. Threading

4. Bobbin

5. Thread tension

6. Stitch length

7. Machine settings

And always test your chosen combination on a scrap of the fabric before starting your finished project.

Coats Moon vs Gütermann Sew-All for Quilting

Both general-purpose polyester threads can be used for many quilting-related sewing tasks.

However, if you're specifically looking for 100% cotton quilting thread, Gütermann Natural Cotton is the more relevant option within the Gutermann range.

Natural Cotton is particularly suited to quilting, patchwork and projects where a natural-fibre thread is preferred.

So if you're deciding between Moon and Sew-All for a quilt, the bigger question might actually be:

Do you want polyester or cotton thread?

If you want polyester, either a suitable Moon or Sew-All thread may work.

If you specifically want cotton, consider Gütermann Natural Cotton.

What About Stretch Fabrics?

This is one area where you need to look beyond the two general-purpose threads.

Coats Moon and Gütermann Sew-All are not specialist elastic sewing threads.

If you're sewing a stretch fabric and need the stitched seam to stretch with the fabric, consider a specialist thread such as Gütermann Maraflex.

Maraflex is designed to create flexible seams using a standard straight stitch and can provide up to 80% seam stretch.

It's particularly useful for:

• Jersey

• Knitted fabrics

• T-shirts

• Stretch dresses

• Close-fitting garments

• Stretch necklines

• Cuffs

Read our Gütermann Maraflex vs Sew-All guide for more detail.

Shop Gütermann Maraflex

Which Has the Best Colours?

There's no simple winner here because colour availability depends on the particular range and retailer.

When choosing thread, we'd recommend prioritising the best match for your fabric rather than choosing a brand first and trying to find a colour afterwards.

At The Yorkshire Sewing Guy, we stock selected ranges of both Gütermann and Coats threads, including a useful selection of everyday colours.

For particularly important colour matching, a physical shade card is always preferable to relying solely on an image on a screen. You can find Gütermann shade cards in our Downloads section.

Colours can appear differently depending on your monitor, device settings, photography and lighting.

Does Gütermann Sew-All Cost More Than Coats Moon?

Prices vary between retailers, spool sizes, promotions and individual colours, so there isn't a permanent price difference that makes one universally cheaper.

When comparing prices, make sure you're comparing like for like.

Look at:

• Spool length

• Thread type

• Fibre

• Price per spool

• Price per metre

A cheaper spool isn't necessarily better value if it contains significantly less thread.

At The Yorkshire Sewing Guy, we aim to offer trusted sewing brands at competitive prices.

Can You Use Gütermann and Coats Threads Together?

Yes.

You don't have to choose one brand and use it exclusively.

For example, you might have:

• Coats Moon in colours you already own

• Gütermann Sew-All for a new project

• Gütermann Natural Cotton for quilting

• Gütermann Maraflex for stretch garments

The important thing is to choose a thread that's appropriate for the project.

There's nothing inherently wrong with having different brands of thread in your sewing collection.

Can You Mix Brands in the Same Project?

In many everyday sewing situations, yes.

If you run out of one brand and need to finish a seam with another suitable thread, the important considerations are the thread type, weight, colour and suitability for the fabric.

For example, using a suitable polyester sewing thread from another reputable manufacturer is not automatically a problem.

However, if you're working on a specialist project, it's always sensible to test the combination before committing to the finished item.

What If I Need Lots of Colours?

If you regularly sew different projects, buying individual spools can gradually build up a large collection.

That's where thread sets can be useful.

A set can give you several colours in one purchase and can be particularly useful for:

• New sewists

• Quilters

• Dressmakers

• Crafters

• Sewing rooms

• Gifts

• Projects requiring several colours

At The Yorkshire Sewing Guy, we stock individual Gutermann threads as well as Gütermann thread sets.

Browse our Gütermann Thread Range

If you already know exactly which colour you need, an individual spool is usually the simplest option.

Coats Moon or Gütermann Sew-All: Which Should You Buy?

If you're still unsure, here's the simple answer.

Choose Gütermann Sew-All if:

✓ You want a versatile general-purpose polyester thread

✓ You already use Gütermann threads

✓ You want to build a Gütermann collection

✓ You want access to specialist Gutermann threads such as Maraflex

✓ You find the colour you need

Choose Coats Moon if:

✓ You want a general-purpose polyester thread

✓ You already use Coats products

✓ You like the Moon range

✓ You find the colour you need

✓ The price and spool size suit your project

And don't forget:

If you're quilting and specifically want 100% cotton, look at Gütermann Natural Cotton.

If you're sewing stretch fabrics, look at Gütermann Maraflex.

Our Verdict

For straightforward everyday sewing, Coats Moon and Gütermann Sew-All are both strong general-purpose polyester thread options.

There isn't a single winner that is best for every sewist.

If you already have a preference for one brand, there's little reason to change simply for the sake of changing.

Instead, consider:

What am I sewing?

What thread fibre do I need?

What colour do I need?

How much thread do I need?

Once you've answered those questions, choosing between Coats Moon and Gutermann Sew-All becomes much easier.

At The Yorkshire Sewing Guy, we stock both brands so you can choose the thread that's right for your project.

Browse our Sewing Threads

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Coats Moon the same as Gütermann Sew-All?

No. They are different thread ranges from different manufacturers, but both are general-purpose polyester sewing threads designed for many of the same everyday applications.

Is Gütermann Sew-All better than Coats Moon?

Not necessarily. Both are good general-purpose polyester threads. The best choice depends on your project, colour requirements, price and personal preference.

Is Coats Moon polyester?

Yes. Coats Moon is a polyester general-purpose sewing thread.

Is Gutermann Sew-All polyester?

Yes. Gütermann Sew-All is a general-purpose polyester sewing thread.

Can I use Coats Moon in my sewing machine?

Yes. Coats Moon is suitable for household sewing machine use.

Can I use Gütermann Sew-All for dressmaking?

Yes. Gütermann Sew-All is a versatile general-purpose thread and is suitable for many dressmaking projects.

Which is better for quilting, Moon or Sew-All?

Both can be used for suitable quilting applications. If you specifically want 100% cotton thread for quilting, Gütermann Natural Cotton is a more relevant option.

Which is better for stretch fabric?

Neither Coats Moon nor Gutermann Sew-All is a specialist elastic thread. For flexible seams in stretch fabrics, Gütermann Maraflex is designed specifically for this purpose.

Can I mix Coats and Gütermann thread?

Yes. You can use suitable threads from different manufacturers in your sewing projects. Always consider the fibre, thread size, fabric and intended use.

Should I choose thread by brand or colour?

For many everyday projects, the correct thread type and a good colour match are more important than choosing one particular brand.

Should I buy individual spools or thread sets?

If you know the exact colour you need, an individual spool is ideal. If you need several colours or are building a sewing collection, our Gütermann thread range includes a number of useful sets and colour packs.